Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
- -
- -- -
Page 1
http://www.advaitin.net/PranipataChaitanya/AdvaitaMakarandaverse04.pdf
destruction of cloth the color and such characters of that cloth also getting
destroyed, you are saying on the destruction of its substratum the Self will
also get destroyed iti vikalpya thus stating different possible
alternatives dyam prati ha starts replying to the first
alternative
na svata pratyabhijnnniraatvnna cnyata |
na crayavinnme vina sydanrayt ||4||
pratyabhijnt because of (there being) continuous memory
Page 2
http://www.advaitin.net/PranipataChaitanya/AdvaitaMakarandaverse04.pdf
recognition is(definition)
- -
prvam-anubhtasya klntare pramena tat tat ullekhaprvakam jnam the knowledge arising in subsequent time of an earlier
experience by digging up those cognitions with assurance tm hi
with respect to the Self
- -
- -
Page 3
http://www.advaitin.net/PranipataChaitanya/AdvaitaMakarandaverse04.pdf
na dvitya iti ha | niraatvt na cnyata iti | niraatvt aarahitatvt nir-avayavatvd anyata hetu-sayogt api tmana na na
iti artha | tm hi cid-rpatvt niravayava | yadi niravayavasya tmana
svayavatvam-ucyeta tarhi vaktavyam tm avayav cetan acetan v |
na dvitya iti ha niraatvt
na cnyata iti not by second(destruction owing to conjunction with
something else) is explained by niraatvt na cnyata portion of the
verse. niraatvt = - aa-rahitatvt since without
Page 4
http://www.advaitin.net/PranipataChaitanya/AdvaitaMakarandaverse04.pdf
- -
na dvitya acetanai avayavai rabdhasya api tmana api acetanatvaprasagt na hi acetanai tantubhi rabdha paa cetana dyate tata
niravayava eva tm na niravayave ca tmani hetu-sayoga sambhavati
satya ekadea-vttitvt ata anyata api tmana na na iti bhva |
na dvitya neither the second proposition
- acetanai avayavai
rabdhasya api tmana api acetanatva-prasagt then of Self too which is
made up of insentient parts we have to attribute insentiency
na hi acetanai tantubhi rabdha paa
cetana dyate as it is not seen in case of a cloth to be sentient which is
made of parts of thread which are insentient tata
niravayava eva tm therefore Self is partless only - na niravayave ca tmani hetusayoga sambhavati satya ekadea-vttitvt in the partless Self the
hetu(destruction owing to conjunction with something else) cannot happen
as then it should join with the other in some point(part/place)
ata anyata api tmana na na iti
bhva Hence as cannot be from within so also from without there is no
destruction to the Self is the conclusion
- -
---
- -
Page 5
http://www.advaitin.net/PranipataChaitanya/AdvaitaMakarandaverse04.pdf
--
-- - --
na api ttya iti ha | na ca raya itydin | raya-vint dhra-vint
api me mama vina na syt kuta anrayt rayasya dhrasya
bhvt | tm hi gua-kriy-jti-di anyatamatva abhvt anraya
niravayavatvt ca na api ghaavat raya | ata raya-nt api tmana
na na | tmana maradi-pratti tu dehdi updhikt | taduktam
strakt -- carcara vyapraya tu syt tad vyapadea bhkta tadbhva-bhvitvd iti | asya ca artha vidyraya-gurubhi adhikaraaratna-mlym darita |
jvasya janmamarae vapuo vtmano hi te |
jto me putra ityukterjtakarmdibhistath ||
-iti prvapake prpte siddhntam ha -
mukhye te vapuo bhkte jvasyaite apekya hi |
jtakarma ca lokoktirjvpeteti strata || iti |
tata trividha na abhvt nitya eva tm iti tasya brahmaa abheda
samyag ghaate iti bhva ||4||
na api ttya iti ha na ca
raya itydin not even by third(on supporters destruction the supported
will also be destroyed) is explained by verse portion na ca raya
Page 6
http://www.advaitin.net/PranipataChaitanya/AdvaitaMakarandaverse04.pdf
taduktam strakt the author of Stras(Brahma sura) has
told thus
--
carcara vyapraya tu syt tad vyapadea bhkta tad-bhvabhvitvd iti |
The moveable and immovable do not apply thereto, the attribution of them
thereto is tropical, because it is that which exists under these modes.
-
-- asya ca artha
vidyraya-gurubhi adhikaraa-ratna-mlym darita the same idea
has been conveyed by Guru Vidyaranya in Adhikarana Ratnamala.
jvasya janmamarae vapuo vtmano hi te |
Advaita Makaranda with Rasa-abhivyanjika
Page 7
http://www.advaitin.net/PranipataChaitanya/AdvaitaMakarandaverse04.pdf
mukhye te vapuo bhkte jvasyaite apekya hi |
jtakarma ca lokoktirjvpeteti strata || iti |
The birth and death pertain primarily to the body, and by a metaphor only to
the self; and the rites at birth and the common saying do not pertain to the
Self, according to the stras.
tata trividha na abhvt
nitya eva tm iti therefore since free from three kinds of destruction, Self
is eternal only. tasya brahmaa
abheda samyag ghaate iti bhva its non-difference with Brahman quite
possible is established.
Page 8