Case 9:11-cv-80880-KLR Document 105 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2012 Page 1 of 5

UNI TED STA TES D I STRI CO U RT CT SOU TH ERN D I STRI O F FLO RI CT DA

Ca eNo.1l 8 o- v- kn p/- ns s - o88 ci Rys m l opki l

( .

QSGI l , ,NC.
Pl ntf, ai if
FI ED ty -L ) D. 2.

l L 25 2 1 U 22
1 GLO BA L FI N CI G,e a . BM NA N t l,
STU 'r U #MIR: VSl k AFI I k!

CL RKu. osrc . E b l' T . s o oFF . w. a, .. L - R

Def nt . enda s
/ O R D ER G R AN TI G I PA RT AN D DEN Y I G I PA R T N N N N DEFENDANTS'REO UEST FOR ATTORNEYS'FEES AND CO STS ( 1 DE 00)

THI CAUSE hascomebef et sCour upon an Or rr f ri a 1dic y m a tr S or hi t de e e rng l s ovel te s

t teu esg e Untd Sae M a itaeJ d ef rfn lds sto .( 41 8 ) o h nd rin d ie tts gsrt u g o i a ipo i n DE , 6 . i
On Jme 1 201 t sCour g a ed Def nda s m oton f s nc i bas d on t 8, 2, hi t r nt e nt ' i or a tons e

Pli ifsfiur t pr uc isCEO M acShema f anotce de ii ( 96) The antf al e o od e t r r n or i d poston. DE .

Cou ti tu t d De enda st s i e de eoft a t ne f esand c t t i un'd asa r nsr c e f nt o ubm t vi nc he tor ys' e oss hey nc e

rs l o M r S ema sfiu et a p a .( 9 ) J n 28 201 , fn a t s b te e ut f . h r n' alr o p e r DE 6 .On u e , 2 Dee d ns u mitd s p e n a p p r se ig$ , 521i c t a d atr y ' e s ( 1 0 .OnJ l 1 , u plme tl a e s e kn 2861 . n oss n tone s f e . DE 0 ) uy 2 2 2 Pli tf fld a o j ci nt t ea t s u h .( 1 4 . 01 , anif ie n be to o h momt o g t DE 0 )
TheCour fndst cossand f e s t i he t e s oughtby De e f ndant t be e r tnt Ac or ngl so xo bia . c di y, t sCour wile r ie isdic e i n i r duci t f esa c t t i hi t l xe c s t s r to n e ng he e nd oss o mpos r s bl e ea ona e

s tons Se Ame ianCi lLi risUni v Bar s 1 F. 423, ( 1hCi.1 anci . e rc vi be te on . ne , 68 3d 427 1 t r 999) (our hasdicei t adus ana r ofat ne 'fes. c t s rton o j t wad tor ys e )

Case 9:11-cv-80880-KLR Document 105 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2012 Page 2 of 5

I f de alc t ar as bl a tr y' f a r i t ope l ca c a e by muli yi n e r our, e ona e to ne s ee wa d s pr ry l ult d tpl ng t num be ofhour r as bl e he r s e ona y xpende tmesa r a ona ehoury r t ' Ame i an Ci l d i e s bl l a e. ' rc vi

Lie te Uninv Ba n s 1 8F.d4 , 7( 1h r 1 9 )( in Blm v Stn o , 6 U. b ris o . r e , 6 3 23 42 1 tCi. 9 9 ct g u . e s n 4 5 S. i 8 6 8 8( 9 4 Thera o a eh u l r t i d fn da tet rv i n make rt i t e 8 , 8 1 9 :. e s n bl o ry ae s e e s h s e al g r t ae n h p i
r l va lgalc e e nt e omm uniy f smia s r i sby lwye sofr a ona y c t or i lr e vce a r e s bl ompa a es ls r bl kil,

e p re c , n rp tto ' Ba n s 1 8F.da 43 ( oigNo ma v Hou igAuh o x e in e a d e u ain. r e , 6 3 t 6 qu t ' n r n . sn t. f

Mo t mey, 3 F.d 1 2,1 9( 1 Ci.1 9 ).Th fea pia tb a st b r e o ngo r 8 6 2 29 29 1 1 r 9 9 ) e e p l n e r he u d n f c
esa ihi t cli e m a ke r t Se Bar s,1 F. a 427.Ge r ly,he Seeva t bls ng he am d r t ae. e ne 68 3d t ne a l s r l nt t mar t f pur esofde e m i ngt r as ke ' or pos t r ni he e onabl houry r t f a a t ne ss r i e i Ehe e l ae or n tor y' e v c s s t

pa ewh r t ec s i fld.'d a 4 7( iig Culn v Ge r aDe ' o r np.2 F.d lc ee h ae s ie ' I . t 3 ctn le s . o gi p t fT a s , 9 3 ' . 1 9 1 9 ( 1hCi.1 9 $.Th Co r ma c nsd rp irho ryrtsa r e t oh r 48 , 4 4 1 t r 9 4 e u t y o i e ro u l ae wad d o t e
a t ne ofs m ia e r e e i t c m t iy a a s t Cour ' ow n know l tor ys i l r xpe i nc n he om m t nd l o he ts edge oft he

rtsc ag db l c l a tto e s S eM c n l e r lPr n ega t . n inPlno h ae h r e y o a prciin r . e Do ad x e. e d r s v Pe so a fte

NYS I Pe i Tr stFu 450F. 91, 97( Ci. A-LA nson u nd, 3d 96- 2d r 2006) dititc tma alous ( src our y s e A

i k o e g o t er lv n ma k t e d tr n n t er a o a l h u l rt .) t n wld e f h ee a t r e wh n eemii g h e s n be o ry ae' . s '

I s n ubmitng ar ue tf a t ne sf es f e a ia sa er uiedt e r ie li ti eq s or tor y' e , e pplc nt r eq r o xe c s s lng bi

j d me t' Ba n s 1 F.da 4 8( u tn He se v Ec e h r, U. 4 4, 3 (98 :. u g n . r e , 68 3 t 2 q o ig n ly . k r a t461 S. 2 4 4 1 3 ' I f ea p ia t d n te riebligj d me tb e cudn i xc sie rd n a t o f e p lc n s o o xecs il u g n y x l ig t e sv , e u d n, r n e

oh r s u ne e s r 'h t s te t ec u t te e cs b l n j d me tfrt e Se te wie n c say' ol ,h n h o r mus x r ie il g u g n o h m. e r i Ba n s 1 8F.da 4 ( ot gNo ma , 3 F.da 1 0 . r e , 6 3 t 28 qu i n r n86 2 t 3)
H e e, e e ntdoesno of e an e a ton f us ng prm a iy N e Y or a t ne r D f nda t f r y xpl na i or i i rl w k tor ys t de e a ns a l w s tt l d i t Sout r D i ti tofFl r da a t ,t Cour w ila y o f nd gai t a ui i e n he he n s r c o i nd hus he t l ppl
2

Case 9:11-cv-80880-KLR Document 105 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2012 Page 3 of 5

c t r a t ne 'f e i t smar t r t rt n def ns c usoma y tor ys e s n hi ke , a he ha e e ouns ' N e Yor Ciy r t .See els w k t aes

Bar s,1 F. a 437Ct tee ntmake 'f pur esofdeemi ngt r s bl ne 68 3d t t rlva he r t or pos tr ni he eaona e houryrt f a at ne ssr c i hepl ewheet c s i fld''( Cule v. l ae or n tor y' e vies s t ac r he a e s ie ')c/ng lns

Ge r aDe ' o r n p.Ba n s 1 8F.d a 4 6 ,1 9 ( 1 Ci.1 9 :. o gi p t fT a s , r e , 6 3 t 3 4 4 1 1 r 9 4 .

Anot c ti t sDititr c ty c udedt ta houry r t of$ 00 wa her our n hi src e en l oncl ha n l a e 400. s
r s bl f a l s le 'i el c a pr t a t ne Se Jac son v Gr poI du . ea ona e or t y kild' nt le m l opery tor y. e k ve . u n s

Hoee o SA. 2 1 W L 75 3 , 3( D. a M ac 3 2 0 .Gie t a Mr S akh st n y tlr , . , 0 0 0 01 * S. Fl. rh , 01 ) v n h t . tr a we t

ye r ofe re ei a ir t1w a i e lc ualpr rywor t Cour wilappl a houry a s xpe inc n nttus a nd nt le t ope t k, he t l y n l

r t of$5 f hi , nd a houry r t of$250. f hi a s a e, n C. s Es ,who ae 00 or m a n l ae 00 or s s ocit Eva Enni, q.

g ad t fo 1 w s hoolt ye r a l r uaed r m a c wo a s go. Def nda s s e nt lpa r i c t t ti a ton t M r St r and M r Enni, e nt ' uppl me a pe s ndia e ha n ddii o . a k . s t e ot ra t ne we e i ved i wor ng on t sma tr Se De a a i ofRiha d J hr e he tor ys r nvol n ki hi te . e clr ton c r .

Str Es ( 1 .Howe r t Cour fndst tDee nt'Motonf rSanci wasnot ak, q.DE 00) ve ,he ti ha fnda s i o tons
s c o ompl x a t r uiet i ve e oftvea t ne .Re e ngM r Str sDe a a i e s o eq r he nvol m nt i tor ys viwi . a k' clr ton, i a a st tM r Er spe f me t bul oft r s a c and dr fi ofDe e nt 'moton t ppe r ha . mi ror d he k he e e r h a tng f nda s i pa r .Ac or ngl t Cour wilalow 1 hour f rM r Enni 'wor a 17ho sf M r pe s c di y, he t l l 4 so . s k nd . ur or . Str swor i r vi i a fnai i t m o i n a r pl pa r . a k' k n e sng nd i lzng he to nd e y pe s W ih r r t def ns c t ega d o e e ouns ' c t ,or na iy,t sCo twoul c l t t els oss di rl hi ur d onc ude ha Pl ntf s d notha t pay f Def nt 'dec son t us outoft ai if houl ve o or enda s ii o e own c ouns la e nd,

t eeo e wo l d ciet a r a yo d fn ec u e ' ta e c t.S eBa l w v S nLf h rf r , u d e ln o wad n f e e s o ns ls rv l oss e ro . u e

1 Thi i ar duc i n fo t $1004. hotry r t s s s e to r m he , 00 ll a e oughtby M r Str a t $355. . a k nd he 00

houryrt s htb M r Enni.Se De aai oflihadJ Str Es ( 1 a pa 3) l ae oug y . s e clrton kc r . ak, q. DE 00 t ge .

Case 9:11-cv-80880-KLR Document 105 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2012 Page 4 of 5

a dHe lhI s Co , 011W L 3 75 98 * ( . Fl. g. 2 1( o r d d ce atme n at n . .2 4 2 , 2 M D. a Au 9, 01 )c u t e u td to y

ta tmefom f ebe us def nda s ul notber quie t pa f rpl ntf sc c t hie r vel i r e ca e e nt ho d e r d o y o ai if hoie o r

c u s l r m o to twn ( iig Ke r e v Au o o n e fo u f o ) ctn a n y . t-own r I s Co , 3F. u p. 1 6 1 7 es n . .71 S p 2d 3 9, 3 9

( . F a 2 0 ) Ho v r b c us Plitf k e t td f n ec u e wo l b ta eig M D. l . 01 ). we e , e a e an if n w ha e e s o ns l ud e rv l n
fom Ne Yor t M im if t deposto bu wat d t i t e ni be or t de ii t r w k o n or he ii n, t ie mtl he ve ng f e he poston o

a s de e e c dvie f ns ouns lt tM r She m a woul nota e ha . r n d ppea , heCo tfndst s cicv sa es rt ur i he e r lm t nc

a e s t i ty e egi t wa r ntr i bm s men of$1,00. i ta lc t Se F. C. r ufk en l gr ous o ra em e t 5 00 n r ve oss. e T v.

Dal y,2011W L 641 9,*2( Col De 21, ltour i e snci wheepat be 381 D. o. c. 201 lc t mpos d a tons r ry
ga e r me y lt notc ' t ca elde ii a ot s lha alea y i uredconsde a e ve fxte l ae i e' o nc poston nd t m e d r d nc r c i r bl

e ns'ta i t Sa Frncs f t de ii . xpe e'rvelng o n a ico or he poston)

C O N C LU SI N O

I i h rb ORDERED t a De e d n s Re u s frAto n y 'Fe sa d Coss( t s ee y h t fn a t' q e t o tr e s e n t DE 1 0 i GM NTED I PART AND DENI I PART.W ihnt nda so t sOr e , 0 )s N ED N t i e y f hi d r
Pli ifs l r i bur eDe e antf ha l em s f ndan sf t ra t ne 'f esa c t a f l : t or hei tor ys e nd oss s olows

M r St r . a k:
M r Enni : . s
Cos s t:

1. ho sx $500. = 7 ur 00
1 hotr x $ 00 = 4 ls 250.

$ 85 00 0. $3, 00 500.
$1. 00 500.
$ 5, 00 850.

TO TA L FE ES A N D CO ST S:

Case 9:11-cv-80880-KLR Document 105 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/25/2012 Page 5 of 5

DONE and O RDERED i Cha n mber t s25da ofJ y, 201 a W e tPam Be c i t s hi y ul 2, t s l a h n he

Sout m Diti ofFl i he srct orda.

J ES M . AM HOPKI NS UN I TED STA TES M A G I STM TE J D GE U Copi st Couns lofRe d e o: e cor