Everand Logo

Welcome to Everand!

  • Discover millions of ebooks, audiobooks, and so much more with a free trial

    Only $11.99/month after trial. Cancel anytime.

    Unavailable
    Loot: The Battle over the Stolen Treasures of the Ancient World
    Unavailable
    Loot: The Battle over the Stolen Treasures of the Ancient World
    Unavailable
    Loot: The Battle over the Stolen Treasures of the Ancient World
    Ebook583 pages9 hours

    Loot: The Battle over the Stolen Treasures of the Ancient World

    By Sharon Waxman

    4/5

    ()

    Currently unavailable

    Currently unavailable

    About this ebook

    A journey across four continents to the heart of the conflict over who should own the great works of ancient art

    Why are the Elgin Marbles in London and not on the Acropolis? Why do there seem to be as many mummies in France as there are in Egypt? Why are so many Etruscan masterworks in America? For the past two centuries, the West has been plundering the treasures of the ancient world to fill its great museums, but in recent years, the countries where ancient civilizations originated have begun to push back, taking museums to court, prosecuting curators, and threatening to force the return of these priceless objects.

    Where do these treasures rightly belong? Sharon Waxman, a former culture reporter for The New York Times and a longtime foreign correspondent, brings us inside this high-stakes conflict, examining the implications for the preservation of the objects themselves and for how we understand our shared cultural heritage. Her journey takes readers from the great cities of Europe and America to Egypt, Turkey, Greece, and Italy, as these countries face down the Louvre, the Metropolitan Museum, the British Museum, and the J. Paul Getty Museum. She also introduces a cast of determined and implacable characters whose battles may strip these museums of some of their most cherished treasures.

    For readers who are fascinated by antiquity, who love to frequent museums, and who believe in the value of cultural exchange, Loot opens a new window on an enduring conflict.

    LanguageEnglish
    PublisherMacmillan Publishers
    Release dateApr 1, 2010
    ISBN9781429960434
    Unavailable
    Loot: The Battle over the Stolen Treasures of the Ancient World
    Author

    Sharon Waxman

    Sharon Waxman is a Hollywood correspondent for the New York Times and previously was a correspondent for the Washington Post covering the entertainment industry. She lives in southern California with her family.

    Related to Loot

    Related ebooks

    Art For You

    View More
    View More

    Related podcast episodes

    Related articles

    • Article

      A Nubian Kingdom Rises

      Aug 13, 2020

      A Nubian Kingdom Rises
      10 min read

    • Article

      Opening Up The British Museum

      Oct 29, 2020

      Opening Up The British Museum
      10 min read

    • Article

      Treasures of Ancient Egypt

      May 28, 2021

      ANCIENT EGYPT PART 2 OF 2 Social sciences FOR more than 3 000 years the Ancient Egyptian civilisation flourished on the banks of the Nile River in northeast Africa. But after Egypt was conquered – first by the Greeks, then the Romans and eventually t

      4 min read

    • Article

      Art

      Jun 13, 2023

      Art
      8 min read

    • Article

      Racism, Natural History, and Fiction

      Sep 7, 2017

      Natural history is not just a grab bag; it’s not neutral, and it’s important that in fiction it not be allowed to become a playground where white people, characters, and authors can retreat into an allegorical fantasy land, as it has functioned in re

      10 min read

    • Article

      History’s Greatest Mysteries

      May 14, 2020

      History’s Greatest Mysteries
      36 min read

    • Article

      Building Bridges

      Jul 2, 2023

      Building Bridges
      3 min read

    • Article

      Room To Imagine

      Apr 1, 2023

      Room To Imagine
      6 min read

    • Article

      Modern Art Painted In A New Light

      Oct 12, 2022

      Revisiting Modern British Art Edited by Jo Baring (Lund Humphries, £39.99) THIS anthology of 12 essays covers British art from the First World War to the Swinging Sixties. It is a well-worn area in the publishing world—recent volumes include Frances

      8 min read

    • Article

      Virtual Tours

      Nov 26, 2020

      Virtual Tours
      3 min read

    • Article

      School Of Rock

      Oct 21, 2022

      School Of Rock
      5 min read

    • Article

      Busted

      Aug 1, 2023

      Busted
      15 min read

    • Article

      Levelling Up Pompeii: Grave Shows How A Former Slave Went Far

      Aug 21, 2021

      The inscription on the gravestone proudly attests to how far Marcus Venerius Secundio, a former slave of the ancient Roman city of Pompeii, went in life. In order of importance, he lists his achievements after being liberated. The first was his role

      3 min read

    • Article

      Preliminaries

      Aug 22, 2022

      Preliminaries
      6 min read

    • Article

      The Face of Fayum in Beijing

      Nov 11, 2021

      The moment I set eyes on one of the Fayum portraits depicting a middle-aged man on a coffin lid in Cairo’s Egyptian Museum, I was hooked. His pensive gaze and striking resemblance with many Egyptian friends put me on a journey of learning more about

      2 min read

    • Article

      King Tut On Exhibit As Views Of Antiquities Evolve

      Oct 23, 2018

      The exhibition embarks on a tour during a time when views among the public seem to have been changing about the true ownership of ancient artifacts that were taken from the countries where they were discovered.

      2 min read

    • Article

      Q&A

      Oct 29, 2020

      Q&A
      3 min read

    • Article

      New Times, New Histories

      Oct 5, 2021

      New Times, New Histories
      11 min read

    • Article

      Turning Heads

      Jun 17, 2022

      Turning Heads
      4 min read

    • Article

      The Inheritance of Nations

      Jun 1, 2021

      The Inheritance of Nations
      7 min read

    Reviews for Loot

    4/5

    62 ratings7 reviews

    What did you think?

    Tap to rate

    Review must be at least 10 words

    • 3/5
      In "Loot" Sharon Waxman attempts to explain the story of how many of the great museums of the West acquired their artifacts, and how they expand upon their collections today. Unfortunately, the author eventually succumbs to a shallow flashiness that leaves the reader without a full understanding of how the antiquity trade operates on a global scale.

      Waxman examines her story primarily through a series of high-profile interviews with prominent operators such as Zahi Hawas, then secretary-general of Egypt's Council of Antiquities (and all-purpose thorn-in-the-side to the curators and collectors of the great museums outside of his country), Neil MacGregor, director of the BM, Philippe de Montebello, director of the Met, and Henri Loyrette, director of the Louvre. Much of the pre-twentieth century collections of these institutions were acquired (though acquired seems far too mild a word for works such as the zodiac ceiling of the Temple of Denderah and half of the statues of the Parthenon, both literally ripped from their masonry) under the auspices of the Ottoman Empire, which was indifferent if not outright hostile to the treasures of other cultures within its boundaries, or during, in the case of Egypt, a corrupt system of partage that existed until the 1920's. She dutifully recounts the early history of archeology since its beginnings in the mid eighteenth century, relying heavily (and I am putting this mildly) on such well-known works such as "Gods, Graves, and Scholars" and especially "The Rape of the Nile" to recount the horrifying antiquities-grab that occured during previous centuries. Waxman goes on to describe how buying objects with questionable--or often entirely unknown provenance--was considered acceptable untl the late 1960's. It was only then than the cultural branch of the UN put into place a series of strictures designed to prevent the looting or smuggling of artifacts.

      It is to the author's credit that she remains objective and tries to examine both sides to this difficult problem. Should an institution be responsible for returning items obtained centuries ago under conditions that would now be considered illegal? Does an object belong to the world or to a particular people-especially when the cultural heirs of that culture have vanished? Is is better to keep a unique object in the holdings of an museum that can display it for more people to wonder over? In the case of an institution that doesn't have the financial ability to keep something safe (the tragic story of the golden hippocampus of the Lydian Horde, returned to the brief custodianship of a tiny provincial museum by a reluctant Met, and now gone, perhaps forever, is described in detail), should an item be returned at all? Does insistence of strict provenance for trading antiquities really help, or does it merely drive the trade underground?

      At this point, I might have given the book four stars. I kept waiting, however, for something more. Waxman makes many digs at the patronizing or even culturally imperialistic stances of Europe and the United States, yet she herself is guilty of this myopic attitude. Of the huge problems of looting and smuggling that exist in Latin America and Asia she breathes not a word.( Only the sack of the statues of Benin are mentioned.) Of the industry of manufactured fakes? Nothing. Does she go out into the field except in Egypt--even to Ceveteri, the great Etruscan site just north of Rome, and the scene of so much looting? No, she does not. Does she make a foray to Geneva, a prominent conduit for so many antiquities due to its status as a free port and talk to a few Swiss paper-pushers and ask them to explain themselves? Nope. This latter omission is simply inexcusable as Switzerland is cited again and again as a problem in the antiquities trade. Indeed, Waxman pretty much confines her investigations to talks with the famous, their overworked curators, and a few rumpled and driven journalists for old time's sake. She scarcely talks to field archeologists, giving only a cursory nod to Jack Davis, head of the consortium of the US universities operating archeology programs in Greece--a person who should have had much more time devoted to his position, which is that most everything should remain in situ to begin with. Indeed, except for Usak, the little museum in Turkey, Waxman confines herself to exploring the cushy and the well-known.


      This could be excused, of course, as perhaps acceptable gaps in an overview that can't do everything. Yet Waxman spends a huge amount of time and space dealing with the case of Marion True, the former antiquities curator for the Getty, who was tried by the Italian government for illegal antiquities trading. This last part of the book, frankly, is an embarrassment. She spends far too much time on the bed-hopping activities of the staff, making the feeble excuse for her own salacious interest that who is sleeping with whom somehow has something to do with greater problems at the Getty. She jets off to Paros, where Ms True bought a house with a questionable mortgage from donors, for a little look-see of the Greek Isles--entirely irrelevant to the greater story. She interviews Giacomo Medici, the source of many of the Getty's gains via Ms True, though she doesn't speak Italian and he doesn't speak English. Would it have killed her to use an interpreter for such an important part of the story? Indeed, her entire understanding of the Italian judicial system seems muddled and confused.

      In the end, Marion True's career is over and the Getty was forced to return many of the highlights of their collection. The author makes a few weak recommendations that museums should do a better job of labeling their works and citing in greater detail where they come from. And there the book ends, not with a bang, but with a whimper.Even the author's last set-piece of the book, as she lingers outside a dealer's showroom window in the fabulously wealthy town of St. Moritz and ponders the treasures within, is more of a reminder that she perhaps cares more for an ego-boosting glamour-trot amongst the great and the good than to really demonstrate the true global ramifications of the international illegal antiquities trade, and the sacking of the world's patrimony.
    • 4/5
      This is a though-provoking look at large encyclopedic museums, their practices in the past and present in dealing with antiquities from across the globe. As the author states, the book raises more questions than answers about cultural patrimony, looting, restitution, who should keep antiquities, and whether the 1970 UNESCO laws really discourage looting or whether they actually foster black market selling of antiquities to individuals which will never be seen by anyone else. I read this book for a book club, and probably would not have picked it up otherwise. However, it was a surprisingly easy read, and very interesting.
    • 5/5
      Another great analysis of the issues of stolen art. This is a vast conspiracy of steal our heritage from public view. Waxman has done an excellent job explaining the complex issues along with the many"public" crooks in the the theft of a country's art.
    • 4/5
      This is one of those books that you have to read if you're into Museum Ethics. Some of the well-known cases of cultural property contention are highlighted and they are each unique situations. Cultural property ownership will never be solved and museums will continually evolve to new schools of thought.
    • 5/5
      Reads like a thriller, in my view, and provides deep context on the anything but black and white issues of who owns antiquities. Waxman tells a story like nobody's business, and this ability raises more questions than answers about a controversy we'll likely never move past.
    • 4/5
      An eye-opening series of accounts of the secret history of your favorite museum installations. In addition to tracing the path that antiquities take from their countries of origin to the national institutions that house them, Waxman continually raises and reraises the ethical question of the organizations and governments that acquire these antiquities in order to preserve them in perpetuity, and the practical desire of returning them to their home regions, where political and social situations may be less than ideal.Basically, the book boils down to this: who does ancient art belong to, the world, or the specific country of origin? Would it deprive the world of something precious to take the Elgin Marbles out of the British Museum, where millions of people who otherwise wouldn't be able to see them, and return them to Greece, where there are serious doubts about the country's ability to continue to preserve them? And what right does one country have over another to say such a thing?
    • 4/5
      A bust of Nefertiti graces the cover of my copy of "Loot" by Sharon Waxman. Some people (not me) have been lucky to see this bust in real life, but most have seen this iconic Nefertiti only in pictures. Where is this bust? Not in Egypt, as you might think. It’s actually in a museum in Berlin. Waxman uses the bust of Nefertiti as one of many, many examples in which ancient treasures end up in other countries. The debate is whether they should be returned to their home countries or not. To sum it up, it depends on a lot of different issues, of which Waxman tries to provide a balanced account.When I read “Loot”, I learned a lot about the circumstances of how some ancient treasures were removed. For example, there is very little left of what used to grace the Acropolis in Greece. It isn’t due to the elements. Many of the marbles were removed and eventually ended up in museums, mainly the British museum. Waxman points out that at the time that they were removed in the early 1800s, the Acropolis had been used as a military garrison by Turks, and sculptures were being used as fortification. Still, pieces of the Parthenon were removed and taken away by the British, and this dismantling was very noticeable, even by the standards of the time. These marbles were also known as the Elgin marbles, because of Lord Elgin financing the removal of them. What I also found sad about these marbles is that eventually, in the 1930s, the British museum botched a cleaning of them — by removing traces of colors that had originally been painted on, and the patina that had grown over time. The marbles were a darker color; the color that the Parthenon is currently; but the museum used harsh chemicals and metal tools to make the marbles an unnatural white color. Currently, there is much dispute between Greece and the British Museum over how these marbles were treated. “Loot” gives much food for thought. It’s not easy to decide to simply return a treasure, such as the bust of Nefertiti, to its home country. There is documentation in this book on how poorly equipped some museums in some countries are to receive and care for these treasures. “Loot” also covers the often-illegal acquistions of ancient treasures that have continued to the recent day; the last part of this book devotes considerable time to the legal issues that the Getty Museum are facing to this day because of the sometimes underhanded way that these pieces were acquired by that museum. I am not sure, however, that so much detail (such as who slept with who) needed to go into the Getty Museum section.Since I appreciate both history and art (ancient and present), I feel that this book is worth reading. Resitution should be considered in a case-by-case manner; that is for sure. However, I learned a lot about the circumstances of these pieces that I wasn’t aware of before.