The Caravan

Casting a Veil

THREE YEARS AGO, on 1 January 2018, an annual gathering of largely Dalit visitors to the memorial of Bhima Koregaon, near Pune, was attacked by mobs led by Hindu-nationalist organisations. For several weeks, these organisations had been trying to rouse the area’s Maratha population against the Dalit Buddhist community. A day after the violence, Anita Sawale, an anti-caste activist who was present at the gathering, filed a first-information report identifying the mobs as followers of the Hindutva leaders Manohar Bhide—who calls himself Sambhaji Bhide—and Milind Ekbote.

However, the Bharatiya Janata Party-led Maharashtra government ensured that little came of Sawale’s complaint. Instead, a week later, on 8 January, a counter FIR was filed by Tushar Damgude, a supporter of Bhide, alleging that incendiary speeches had been delivered at the Elgaar Parishad, an event organised by Dalit and Left organisations, on 31 December 2017, which led to violence at Bhima Koregaon the next day. The state government chose to make Damgude’s complaint the focus of the investigation, implying that it was the Dalit attendees who had perpetrated the violence. This ran contrary to reams of video, photo and testimonial evidence that showed mobs with saffron flags attacking the Dalit crowd, which has been gathering peacefully every year at the memorial for decades. The organisers of Elgaar Parishad were branded as “urban naxals,” even though they included people such as the retired Supreme Court judge PB Sawant and BG Kolse Patil, a former judge at the Bombay High Court. Several human-rights activists, lawyers and intellectuals, all of whom had been critical of the government, were arrested. In October 2019, the BJP was unseated in the Maharashtra state elections and, as a result, lost control of the state’s police. The National Investigation Agency, controlled by the BJP-led central government, jumped to wrest control of the case from the Pune police, ensuring that the case did not change directions, and that activists and lawyers remained in jail.

The BJP has been particularly successful in controlling the narrative. The activists’ arrests across states and the transfer of the case to the NIA have allowed the BJP government to completely dislocate the conflict from its regional context and characterise it as a “national” threat. Dissenting voices, on the other hand, have situated this episode within two discourses: the attack on civil liberties, including the criminalisation of dissent, by an authoritarian regime; and the history of Dalit politics, including the discussion over the meaning associated with the memorial of Bhima Koregaon.

This has helped the BJP hide the insidious politics played at the local level by Hindutva organisations in Maharashtra. This national characterisation by the BJP, and the focus on Bhima Koregaon matter as only a Dalit issue, pulls the attention away from the regional dynamic in which this episode is rooted. The ideological and economic conflicts within the Maratha caste cluster is at the heart of this episode, as are the state’s electoral politics, which has always been feeding into

Stai leggendo un'anteprima, registrati per continuare a leggere.

Altro da The Caravan

The Caravan18 min lettiPolitical Ideologies
The Biased Referee
On 12 March, the Election Commission announced an unprecedented eight-phase polling schedule for West Bengal’s 294 assembly seats and a three-phase one for 126 seats in Assam. The way the phases have been marked out has drawn attention, especially si
The Caravan3 min letti
The Bookshelf
Between 2013 and 2016, Project 39A, a criminal-justice research-and-litigation centre, interviewed death-row prisoners and their family members. This book is a counterpart to the Death Penalty India Report based on these interviews, with 19 snippets
The Caravan28 min lettiPolitics
Battle Royal
SINCE NOVEMBER LAST YEAR, protests have erupted throughout Nepal, including in the cities of Butwal, Biratnagar, Dhangadhi, Pokhara, Janakpur and Kathmandu. While civil and political protests are a strong and regular feature of Nepali politics, these