This Week in Asia

A global China must ask itself awkward questions. Is it ready?

An essay by Tsinghua University professor Xu Zhangrun, a veiled criticism of Chinese President Xi Jinping, has resonated across the internet since its appearance late last month. The essay, which has been repeatedly wiped off the Chinese internet, voices a profound unease about the direction of Chinese politics. Talking to Chinese writers and academics in the past year, I've also been struck by their sense of uncertainty. Historical topics that were fine to write about just a few years ago can't now be published. Contemporary political issues, such as potential flaws in the Belt and Road project, aren't being debated in the media, even if they are the subject of furious discussion offline.

Xu Zhangrun, Tsinghua University law professor. Photo: sohu

Meanwhile, Xu's essay is an example of a historical phenomenon that has occurred repeatedly in Chinese history, particularly in the modern era: the warning from an intellectual to the leader that the country may be on the wrong path.

Some of the most intellectually productive eras in modern Chinese history have been times of political weakness. The "new culture" period around the May Fourth demonstrations of 1919 was one such, sitting in the middle of the "warlord" era of Chinese politics. Much of the second world war saw a huge amount of political debate and pluralism. A third such period took place in the 1980s, at the end of the Cultural Revolution.

China's vulnerability provided a reason for thinkers to feel urgency about new solutions, but also left gaps in the public sphere that allowed criticism to emerge clearly. In contrast, strong leadership has often meant new thinking is stifled.

Sima Qian, the grand historian of the Han court, was sentenced to castration for criticising one of the emperor's judgments. Photo: SCMP

Chinese intellectual life has never wanted for critiques of the state or government. What it has lacked is a regulated place for those critical voices to exist safely. When Sima Qian, the grand historian of the Han court, criticised one of the emperor's judgments in 99BC, he was sentenced to castration.

Critics who speak truth to power and suffer the consequences recur often in Chinese history. Something else also differentiates the intellectuals who speak out in China from their equivalents in cold-war era Eastern Europe. The Andrei Sakharovs and Vaclav Havels were thinkers who were in clear opposition to the state. In China, much potent criticism has come from thinkers who have worked within the system.

In the pre-war period, Jiang Tingfu became one of China's best-known historians. In the 1930s, he also became a well-known critic of the Kuomintang government. However, Jiang was tapped by Chiang Kai-shek to hold a variety of major positions, including ambassador to the USSR, and eventually to the United Nations.

The Kuomintang was no great respecter of human rights or democracy, and its thugs gunned down cultural figures such as the poet Wen Yiduo in 1946. But it did not have an ideological prohibition on free speech as a point of principle and was on occasion able to see that criticism might be productive.

A statue of China's famous poet Wen Yiduo in Tsinghua University, Beijing. Photo: Simon Song

The Mao era saw a much stronger government, but it subordinated freedom of discussion to the demands of the party. In the Cultural Revolution, discussion of political alternatives to Mao's rule were regarded as close to sacrilege. When Deng Xiaoping took power in 1978, he stressed the importance of "seeking truth from facts" and allowing thinkers to put forward their own views.

In summer 1988, an astonishing programme called Heshang (River Elegy) was shown on national television. It condemned the "peasant emperor" Mao, and advocated opening up to the "blue water" of the Pacific - a clear signal that China should become closer to the United States.

The writers of the provocative series were a pair of well-known intellectuals, Su Xiaokang and Wang Luxiang. But their criticism was not passed around like Soviet-era samizdat on badly copied carbon paper. It was broadcast for all to see on China's most important television station, because they had a friend in the highest of places - Zhao Ziyang, the Communist Party's then-secretary general.

Former reformist Communist Party general secretary Zhao Ziyang. Photo: Reuters

In the end, the 1989 Tiananmen crisis doomed both Zhao and the intellectuals who were protected by him. Yet even earlier, in the 1980s, there were conflicts about how far the intellectuals could go.

Mao's former political secretary Hu Qiaomu became the first honorary president of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences when it was founded in 1977 as a think tank for clear, objective policy that would "seek truth from facts", as Deng asked. A decade later, Hu was purging moderate academics whose supposedly "bourgeois" views offended his leftist sensibilities.

Hu Qiaomu

Hu Qiaomu died over two decades ago. But the legacy of his actions remains relevant today as China's thinkers ask: can an intellectual speak objectively and not fall foul of politics? China seeks to lead in areas from technology to international development to global governance. To succeed, it will need to ask awkward questions. How can we create a system whose actions are predictable?

This article originally appeared on the South China Morning Post (SCMP).

Copyright (c) 2018. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.

Altro da This Week in Asia

This Week in Asia5 min lettiWorld
Oxygen On Taobao: How Chinese And Indian Expats Are Sending Life-saving Covid-19 Equipment To Help Combat India's Second Wave
Ghosh works for one of the biggest investment funds in China and has lived in the mainland for over a decade. Over the past 10 days, as the devastating second wave of the pandemic sweeps through his homeland, he has been familiarising himself with ox
This Week in Asia3 min letti
Zero-emission, Guilt-free Flights From Hong Kong To Da Nang May Soon Be Possible
Do you have questions about the biggest topics and trends from around the world? Get the answers with SCMP Knowledge, our new platform of curated content with explainers, FAQs, analyses and infographics brought to you by our award-winning team. COP T
This Week in Asia3 min lettiMedical
Coronavirus: Malaysia To Enter New Lockdown As Muhyiddin Warns Of National Crisis
Malaysia will impose a nearly month-long nationwide partial lockdown starting on Wednesday, the government has said, as new Covid-19 cases continue to rise ahead of this week's celebration of the end of the Islamic holy month of Ramadan. Prime Minist